I have been reading comments online about stealing site content. Whilst I admit to finding this annoying I feel there is little can be done about it. Obviously if they steal your post “in verbatim” along with photographs and personal comments, then you can. If it is just the ingredient and method, what proof do you have unless the recipe is unique? I have seen hundreds of recipes online similar to some I regarded as my own – made up by my own hands (with a little bit of input from the brain), in the 1960s.
Unless you have written notes or have undeniable proof that you were the first person to post such a recipe on a site, you can´t. I have written notes going back years, some of the quite unique, but mostly just common and garden recipes that many people have a version of. I have one recipe written in my own childish handwriting – late 1950s – I found the identical recipe on a site!
For instance, mother has two daughters – each of us take Mum´s recipe from when she taught us how to cook. We each make minor amendments, years on both claim the recipe. But who owns the recipe? Could perhaps Mum and her sisters have done the same thing, taken Grandma´s recipes, made minor changes and again claimed them as their own? Generations down the line, two strangers, but who are distantly related say “you stole my recipe”!
We put our recipes on our site/s, fully aware that “someone” will come along and pinch them, probably more than one “someone”. You can shout and yell all you want, what will be will be. I have found several of my recipes online, copied word for word onto a site, including my spelling mistakes and bad grammar. What can I do, well complain obviously, but if they say “it is mine, not yours”, and they are prepared to fight to keep it on their site, what can you go to and is it worth it in the end?
I watched Spanish TV – one of their chefs did a tortilla (or omelette) – it was mine down to the last ingredient – made with store cupboard ingredients left in an otherwise empty pantry and fridge, very unique. He claimed it as his own and gave it a new name.
I found a recipe on a well known British site – an old recipe I concocted one night when I fancied a cheese and apple pie, shortly after marrying in the late 1960s, but did not have a recipe – I wrote the recipe and method in an old recipe book from the 1920s. The chef claimed it as her own. The method and ingredients were (for the most part) the same as my handwritten notes with very minor changes – for instance increasing the sugar by 1/2 ounce and adding “serve with cream”!
What really annoys me is when a TV chef pinches a recipe like my apple and cheese pie, then puts it on a site and slaps a copyright clause in there, and she pinched it in the first place. Dishonest, oh yes! Can I do anything about it? Unlikely.
Update – this chef has now changed the method so it is now quite different. The fact remains – she “borrowed” it in the first place, though now she has made changes, she has now “borrowed” the idea – along with another person who has made in into a Lancashire recipe!
